Looking for Feedback

I'm looking for feedback on what I should be spending my time on with my game. I'm a one-man show, so "everything" really isn't the answer. If I focus more on gameplay mechanics, that's time taken away from graphics. If I spend more time on graphics, that's less time on writing scripts. I do plan on spending time on all aspects of the game, but how I balance that time will be partly based on feedback I get. 

 Ultimately, I want a game that people can enjoy, and the story is the most important part of it to me, so anything related to storytelling (writing, graphics, lighting, pacing, exposition, world-building), is what I'm looking for. However, gameplay is part of the storytelling in games, so I do need to do enough on that end to make the game something people will spend their valuable time playing. So if the gameplay isn't good enough to keep people engaged, I do want to know that.